Each has its own advantages. If it is used to keep out the cold, the cloak has a better effect, while the shawl has a stronger decorative effect, and its ability to keep out the cold is not as strong as that of the cloak. From an aesthetic point of view, shawls look better. Shawls were popular in Ming and Qing dynasties, and were mostly used in social occasions such as weddings and receptions. There is also a shawl collar, double-breasted and ankle-length, which is not as beautiful as a shawl.