So the answer is: the mass of aluminum block is directly proportional to its volume.
(3) Comparing the data (1), (2) and (3) in Table 2 of Student B, it can be seen that the measurement of water quality is obviously wrong, because he "measured their total mass after adding water into the beaker, and then measured the volume of water with a measuring cylinder", so it is very likely that the total mass did not subtract the mass of the beaker, leading to the incorrect experimental conclusion.
So the answer is: Student B made mistakes in the experiment, and the water quality measurement was wrong, and the total mass did not subtract the mass of the beaker, which led to the incorrect experimental conclusion.