There are two records of Ba Fujin's death: the bones were shattered and the ashes were raised. According to the Chronicle of Qing History, in February of Yongzheng four years, Quinn's wife committed suicide, burned the body and raised the ashes. There is no such record in Ju Ju Zhu and A Record of Emperor Sejong Xian. However, in a record, there is a paragraph worth noting: "I never intended to punish the cloud tour, I know this performance." Yunyun's wife, I'll give you another idea and an order. " Prove that Ba Fujin has not been sentenced to death at this time. I don't know why it is so arbitrary to say that Bafujin is dead.
The above remarks in Records of the History of the Qing Dynasty should come from this passage in Yongxianlu: "Another sage once sent a letter to the Qing Dynasty. Yunsu's wife was very unmarried and Yunsu was very afraid of her. Today, Yunyou's wife is violent and heartless, still abusing her husband, and because she punished her family, she didn't show it and instigated her husband, which led to extreme confusion. It's disgusting to drive her back to her parents' house, but she has no fear. It is unbearable to be allowed to live in affluence ... Shu Ren allowed his wife to commit suicide and still scattered her bones to cover up her misery. Scattering bones will raise ashes. If a cloud is buried by Shu Ren, it is not the fault of the government, then the Zongren government will discuss the crime. " If it is written in the Records of Yongxian and taken out of context, it is obviously problematic to regard the crime of Zongrenfu as the seal of Yongzheng.
As a matter of fact, Yongzheng is indeed a "detailed action, another imperial edict." Yongzheng five years, YunZuo YunChan is dead, Yongzheng really decided to deal with their families (such as downstairs):
December 3 rd, Yongzheng five years
Prince Kang Chong 'an and others called for the execution of the wives of Achina and Seth Black.
According to the imperial edict, Achina and Cecily have ulterior motives, messed up our country, committed heinous crimes, disloyal and unfilial, and committed the great crime of betraying the country's Lord and going against the sky. Naturally, all princes abide by national laws and want to bring the wives of Achina and Ceci Black to justice. There has always been a man who rebelled against the usurper in history, but before the rebellion, he openly dared to confront the monarch. This is a great rebellion, and no one is as polite as Achina and Seth Black, which is unheard of since ancient times. However, although Achina and Seth Black committed heinous crimes, the deeds of rebellion were not revealed. His wife is immune from judicial trial. Seth Black's wife was driven back to her parents' home and was strictly forbidden. Aquinas Seth Black's family was handed over to the head of the Ministry of the Interior and was sheltered and cared for.
-"Imperial Decree Pavilion"
Yongxianlu records the emperor's opinions on the handling of Ba Fujin when Zongren House discussed the crime. It was published in the official copy at that time, but Zong Renfu's exposition of crimes was not Ba Fujin's ultimate fate. In fact, in February of the fourth year of Yongzheng, Yongzheng's opinions on the treatment of princes and ministers had not yet been decided and needed to be considered, so he said, "I didn't mean to punish Yunyan. I know the play." Yunyun's wife, I'll give you another idea and an order. "("A Record of Sejong Xian ",Volume 41) Until December 3rd, the fifth year of Yongzheng, Yunzuo and others had died, and the potential threat he faced had been completely eliminated. He doesn't need to embarrass the families of the deceased, but to discuss things and let himself bear the name of a remnant.
As a result, the name of the remnant has been recited for hundreds of years, alas!
Because Yongzheng sentenced Ba Fujin to death, the behavior of throwing bones and ashes was really weird, even the old Ba Laojiu was spared. There is no reason to be so cruel to bafujin. Even if it is sentenced to death, it is really strange to throw bones and ashes. So for a long time, in order to explain this abnormal behavior, there have been various statements. I don't want to interfere with the author's writing ideas, but I don't want people who read the article to regard "Ba Fujin was sentenced to death and there were no bones left" as a historical fact and have an objective prejudice against Yongzheng.