Cao Cao Can can be said to cherish Guan Yu very much, more than any military commander under his account. We found that Cao Cao has a characteristic, and he especially likes generals with high martial arts. When Cao Cao meets a general with strong fighting capacity, he often shows deep desire. Let's give a few examples:
Cao Cao's army fought the Yellow Scarf Army in Gepi and met Xu Qi, Dian Wei and Xu Qi. "From morning till night", the number of lilies is juxtaposed, and there is no difference between fighting and night. "Fuck, I'm scared." Come and watch the game in person. When Cao Cao met Xu Kun, he was "exulting at his prestige", so he deliberately took it for his own use.
On the way to Xuchang, Cao Cao held Emperor Han Xian hostage, but was stopped by Yang Feng. At that time, Huang Xu, who was still working under Yang Feng, went out to fight. When Cao Cao went out to watch, he was "amazed at Huang Xu's good command" and was relieved to see that Huang Xu and Xu Qi were neck and neck.
In the battle of Guandu, Cao Cao and Yuan Shao squared up, and Cao Cao ordered Zhang Liao to challenge him. Yuan Shao's army, Zhang Heting, came to meet the enemy, and the two generals fought forty or fifty games regardless of the outcome. "Cao Cao was surprised to see it." Later, Zhang He surrendered and became a favorite of Cao Cao.
Zhao Yunchang Banpo broke through with Young Master A Dou, and went in seven times and out seven times. Cao Cao saw him "unstoppable wherever he went" on the top of Jingshan Mountain. Knowing that it was Zhao Yun, he ordered "If Zhao Yun comes, don't stab him in the back, just take him alive". Zhao Yun was able to go to deus ex, largely because of this order of Cao Cao. Note that Zhao Yun made his first appearance and saved Gongsun Zan in Panhe. In the book, he described Zhao Yun's appearance as "eight feet long, with heavy eyebrows and eyes, broad-minded and imposing".
Cao Cao conquered Hanzhong and Zhang Lu and met Pound, the old general of Ma Chao. Cao Cao learned about Pound's bravery in the battle of Weiqiao, but he told the generals not to hurt Pound, but to take wheel-and-wheel warfare for their own use. People praised Pound's martial arts and Cao Cao was "overjoyed". In fact, in the battle of Weiqiao, Cao Cao immediately confronted Ma Chao and saw that Ma Chao was handsome and mighty. "Pound first, Ma Dai second. Cao Cao secretly marveled: "Cao Cao appreciates the Great Xia of Xiliang very much. "
Everyone has noticed that as long as Cao Cao "secretly marvels", the generals of the other side will have extraordinary martial arts, and Cao Cao especially likes "majestic" generals.
It can be seen that Cao Cao's favorite soldier has three characteristics: 1. Strong martial arts; 2. Tall; 3. majestic.
Needless to say, Guan Yu's martial arts, the battle of heaped-up mountains, struggled to repel the joint attack of Xu Qi and Huang Xu, is unparalleled in the Cao Wei camp.
Guan Yu's height and appearance also meet Cao Cao's requirements. Guan Yu made his debut in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms, which described Guan Yu's appearance:
Guan Yu is very tall and handsome. He is nine feet tall and "majestic", which is exactly what Cao Cao likes. You should remember that Cao Cao had surrendered to Wei Yan at the Battle of Yangpingguan. Why did Cao Cao surrender to Wei Yan? Everyone looked at Wei Yan: "He is eight feet long and his face is as heavy as a jujube; Wei Yan and Guan Yu look alike, and they are tall and "like dates". "As soon as Cao Cao saw Wei Yan, he thought of Guan Yu and began to soothe.
Cao Cao didn't say anything to Guan Yu, but gold got on the horse, silver got off the horse, a small banquet was held on the third day, and a big banquet was held on the fifth day, giving the beautiful woman a BMW and a brocade robe. They were well paid and wooed by many parties. It can be said that they are extremely spoiled. When Guan Yu left, Cao Cao could not bear to part with him. "It's interesting to sigh on the road and feel that the clouds are long."
In Cao Wei's army, Xia Houdun is undoubtedly a general with the highest status, the oldest qualifications and the heaviest prestige. Cao Cao won't change this, after all, he is his own brother, and he can rest assured that he will be given military power; For Xia, Cao Cao didn't really trust him. It was not until Zhang Lu was pacified and Hanzhong was taken over that it was allowed to take over and guard Hanzhong. For Cao Ren, a member of the Cao Shi clan, Cao Cao trusted him. Coss is both wise and brave, and mature and steady, which makes Cao Cao feel at ease to use. As for Cao Hong, Cao Cao did not give too much promotion and care, and often severely criticized him.
If Guan Yu stays under Cao Cao's account, his martial arts will be the first, and no one can beat him; If the position in the army is concerned, it should be second only to Xia Houdun, and equal to Coss, who was given a unique responsibility by Cao Cao. If the theory is trusted by Cao Cao, it should even be above Coss, second only to Xia Houdun.
If Guan Yu stayed under Cao Cao because of Liu Bei's death and other reasons in history, then he could rank first among generals with other surnames. Cao Cao likes Guan Yu very much. In history, Cao Cao conquered Xuzhou, defeated Liu Bei and captured Guan Yu. As soon as Guan Yu surrendered, he was made a partial general. We can compare Yu Jin and others to see Guan Yu's position at this time.
Before the battle of Xiangfan was defeated by Guan Yu, Yu Jin was Cao Cao's most valued general. Cao Zhou followed him around. At this time, he was just a general, one level lower than Guan Yu. Lejin followed Cao Cao's troops from the left and right, and made a lot of military achievements first. At this time, he just wanted to win over a captain. Like Yu Jin, Huang Xu, who switched from Yang Feng to Cao Cao, was also a general. Zhang Liao is a little earlier than Guan Yu. After the defeat of Lu Bu, he voluntarily led the troops to surrender and was named a corps commander.
These generals, Cao Cao's most trusted physical names later, have lower positions than Guan Yu, who was just caught, which shows Cao Cao's love for Guan Yu.
Guan Yu's starting point is higher than that of Forbidden People, and Cao Cao loves him so much. If he doesn't leave, then Cao Cao will definitely reuse him and have more opportunities to show himself than Forbidden People. Moreover, Guan Yu's ability is not bad. He is not only good at martial arts, but also has the reputation of being an enemy of ten thousand people. He once killed Yan Liang in the White Horse Army, and he also had a strong ability to unify troops. The battle of Xiangfan defeated Cao Ren and Yu Jin, which was a great shock to China.
Have the opportunity to show, strong ability, then Guan Yu's development prospects under Cao Cao will certainly not be bad. According to the ban, Guan Yu was named General Zuo in the 21st year of Jian 'an. Guan Yu's promotion will not be slower than his, only faster.
However, Cao Cao is suspicious, and pays more attention to people of the same clan as Cao Cao and Xiahou, such as Xia, Coss and Cao Hong. , have been reused by Cao Cao. Guan Yu, after all, is a person with a foreign surname, so even if he surpasses them, he will be worse than them in actual strength.
So on the whole, if Guan Yu stays under Cao Cao, it is not a big problem to become the first general with another surname, but it is worse than Xia Houdun and others.
It is not easy to be the first and second in the whole, so it is better to be the first in the whole. Maybe when Pixel says this answer, many people will ask questions. After all, Guan Yu is our "warrior saint" and has hardly lost his life. Cao Cao's men, Chu, Zhang Liao, Dian Wei, Zhang He, were no match for Guan Yu. Why can't Guan Yu be the first?
The ranking of a military commander is determined not only by the force value of the military commander, but also by many factors.
Needless to say, Guan Yu's force value, the title of "warrior saint" that future generations can give him represents everything. Let's talk about the primary factor besides the value of force-commanding operations.
Guan Yu is still very good at this point. The Seventh Army of Fancheng escaped from the ban, beheaded Pound, and was flooded in World War I, so that Cao Cao almost moved the capital. From this point of view, there is no opponent in Cao Cao's camp, and the command and use of troops can rank first (military commanders such as Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi are not included).
Let's talk about Guan Yu. He is headstrong and very arrogant. Of course, he has this capital arrogance. Guan Yu, who looked down on everyone, said that Ma Chao was a migrant worker and Huang Zhong was an old man, and he did not deserve to be an equal. Sun Quan is not even a dog. If Huarong Road had not released Cao Cao, it is estimated that even Zhuge Liang would not have accepted it.
If Cao Caogan did this, it goes without saying that Jia Xu, Sima Yi and others can't deal with it. These geniuses will have one hundred ways to make Guan Yu get along in Cao Wei.
Fortunately, Cao Cao really likes Guan Yu, and Guan Yu once worked under Cao Cao. After the imperial edict, he was forced to write a letter to Cao Cao once. Cao Cao immediately named him a partial general, and after the siege of White Horse, he was promoted to Hou Ting, Han Shou.
Even when he learned that Guan Yu could not stay, he let him go. Cao Cao knew that Guan Yu and Liu Bei would eventually become a menace, but Cao Cao let Guan Yu go. Cao Cao's generals even tried to intercept Guan Yu after learning that Guan Yu had left, but Cao Cao stopped him.
Cao Cao's love can make up for some shortcomings, but Guan Yu can't compete with all kinds of intrigue of those geniuses after all, and if Guan Yu really takes refuge in Cao Cao, then Cao Cao probably won't reuse Guan Yu, because what Cao Cao really appreciates is Guan Yu's loyalty. Losing loyal Guan Yu will only make Cao Cao feel duplicity and may not put Guan Yu's trust before his brothers.
But anyway, if Guan Yu really voted for Cao Cao, he would not be our warrior. After all, the most important reason why Master Guan is Master Guan is because of his loyalty.
Guan Yu has always been famous for his loyalty. Cao Cao likes him not only because of his extraordinary skills, but also because of Guan Yu's unswerving friendship with Liu Bei. Lu Bu is more capable than Guan Yu. In the official history of the Three Kingdoms, Lu Bu was also called "Flying General". Cao Cao not only refused to take him in, but also destroyed him after he finished. That's because Lu Bu's character is too reneging.
If Guan Yu submits to Cao Cao, maybe Liu Bei is dead, and Cao Cao may have a little hope. If Liu Bei were alive, Cao Cao would be far behind Guan Yu. Although Guan Yu stayed in Cao Ying for half a year, he was still there. His heart was in Han (Shu Han) and Cao Cao loved talents. So he valued and respected Guan Yu. He not only sent gold and silver, beautiful women, but also a red hare. Cao Cao saw that Guan Yu's shirt was broken and changed it into a new one. In front of Cao Cao, Guan Yu put the new shirt given to him under the old robe, which embarrassed Cao Cao.
If Guan Yu submits to Cao Cao, he is the first-class warrior under Cao Cao and the general of Xu Weichu in Yunnan. First of all, Guan Yu's skill is obvious to all. There is no lack of opportunism in the resources of "cutting Yan Liang and killing Wen Chou", but all is fair in war since ancient times, which shows that Guan Yu is not only capable, but also more intelligent. This is what a reckless person does.
In the novel, Guan Yu is described as nine feet tall and two feet long. If the face is like a red date and the lips are coated with fat; Cheng Yan, lying silkworm eyebrow. Exaggerated, Guan Yu is a dignified man, and he is not angry and arrogant wherever he goes. Cao Cao likes and misses Guan Yu very much, but he is very upset because he can't get it.
If Guan Yu really surrendered to Cao Cao, Cao Cao would not mistreat him, and the high fever would certainly be better than before. Guan Yu is a military commander, and Cao Cao is both wise and brave. Perhaps with Guan Yu's participation, Cao Cao is at least much better than without Guan Yu. Although he agrees with Cao Cao's ability, he doesn't agree with Cao Cao's life, so with his character, he won't give in.
What if Master Guan defected to Cao Cao in history? Is this a hypothesis? Master Guan was captured and surrendered to Cao Cao! Note that you are willing to surrender, not to defect! This is the truth of history. Because it is surrender, it is more important to earn performance! This just risked his life to stab Yan Liang in the army!
Guan Yu's surrender was downplayed by later generations, although it was not a shameful thing to surrender in the Three Kingdoms, and Cao Cao was best at surrendering and rebelling. Even Liu Bei was not a traitor and might have been admitted by Lu Bu long ago. Cao Cao was also very kind to rebel generals. Among the five outstanding generals, Zhang Liao, Zhang He and Huang Xu are all generals, so he is also very kind to Guan Yu.
The reason why later generations continue to downplay and whitewash Guan Yu's surrender is that they have compiled a story of "Three Things of Tushan, none other than Cao", mainly because the moral standards of Confucianism in later generations have become harsh, and Guan Yu has to be put on the altar, packaged as a saint, and loyal to the monarch forever, so he has to be concealed.
Although Cao Cao was kind to the generals, he sometimes gave the opportunity to lead troops and reward their achievements, but these people still could not enter the core of the army and become truly independent leading generals. The real core is, Xia,, Coss, etc. , and later xelloss, Cao Zhang, Cao Xiu, Cao Zhen and other children. This is a historical fact. Five sons and good generals are all subject to these people.
Guan Yu was well aware of these situations, so when he knew that Liu Bei was not dead, he immediately abandoned Cao and returned to Liu. This is a very utilitarian choice. In Liu Bei's place, although the strength is not yet good, Liu Bei was branded as a clan in the Han Dynasty and was received everywhere. Guan is the second child around Liu Bei.
Why did Cao Cao let Guan Yu leave? One is that Cao Cao is broad-minded, and the other is that no matter how capable a person is, he must have soldiers, strength and trust, otherwise a person is of little use.
Things in the Three Kingdoms were messed up by the romance. Many people think that romance is the fighting mode of ancient wars, so they are biased and say nothing!
In terms of martial arts, Guan Yu should be ranked second. If you are in a position, Guan Yu comes first and no one can. Taoyuan knot used to be beautiful, and the crescent dragon blade was cold.
Riding a thousand miles, five levels will shake Kun Gan.
Loyalty to serve the country is the pillar, and courage protects brothers and casts iron shoulders.
Once I went to Maicheng and never came back, the hero temple went up in smoke.
Under the account, a strong man has a standard gentleman. He ranked Guan Yu in the second place because of Dian Wei. Of course, when Guan Yu sent Cao, Dian Wei had been dead for a long time, but on the whole, I personally think that Dian Wei is better than Guan Yu.
A, Dian Wei, burly, arm strength, it is said that once the army yamen flag was blown down by the wind, yamen flag was so big and long that no one could lift it, so Dian Wei lifted it with one hand. After following Cao Cao, he once "chased the tiger across the river" because he bravely crowned the three armed forces (in the romance, Xia Houdun called him a coach because he saw Dian Wei chasing the tiger across the river), which was called "Ancient Hubei" by Cao Cao.
Who's Eli? That was the first man who became a warrior in Shang Dynasty. He once killed a wild animal by himself.
You know, Guan Yu was appraised as a "warrior" by later generations, and when Dian Wei followed Cao Cao, Cao Cao had already met Guan Yu when the 18th Route Governors begged Dong Zhuo. At that time, Guan Yu first chopped Hua Xiong with warm wine, and then Lu Bu's brave performance in the Three British Wars. Cao Cao did not give Guan Yu such a high evaluation. After seeing Dian Wei's performance, Cao Cao compared him to Loy. Visible Dian Wei's performance is slightly better than Guan Yu's, at least Cao Cao thinks so greatly.
Second, Dian Wei is the only military commander in the record who confronted Lu Bu head-on and repelled him.
In the first year of Xingping, Cao Cao and Lu Bu fought in Puyang. At that time, Cao Cao led an army to attack Lu Bu's troops in the west of Puyang. At this time, Lu Bu personally led the reinforcements to arrive, and the two sides fought from morning till night. The situation in Cao Jun is worrying. Cao Cao temporarily recruited candidates trapped in enemy lines, and Dian Wei took the lead. In addition, he also led dozens of others to sign up. They are all reloaded with two helmets, not shields, but spears and halberds. At the same time, the western war was in an emergency, and Dian Wei rushed to stop the enemy. Lu Bu's arrows rained down, and Dian Wei completely ignored them. He said to his entourage, "The thief army will arrive in ten steps, so you can say it." Soon the waiter said, "Ten steps." Dian Wei added, "Tell me in five steps." The follower was afraid and immediately said, "The thief army has arrived!" Dian Wei shouted, took a dozen small halberds and threw them at the enemy, and all the throwers fell to the ground. Lyu3 bu4 saw that Dian Wei was too brave and had to quit the battlefield.
So from the perspective of martial arts, I personally think that Dian Wei is the first and Guan Yu is the second.
If calculated by status, Guan Yu should be the first person besides Eight Tiger Riding.
Eight Tiger Riding refers to eight clan commanders in Cao Cao's army. They are Xia Brothers, Cao Hong, Coss, Cao Chun, Cao Xiu, Cao Zhen and.
These eight men may not be as good as Guan Yu in martial arts and military tactics, but they are all relatives of Cao Cao, who is suspicious by nature, so the main command of the army is in their own hands. Especially after the trip to the Three Kingdoms, this feature can be clearly seen in the rationing of the Sixth Army Corps under Cao Cao.
Yangzhou Legion, responsible for fighting against Wu's front line, overseers and commanders.
Legion, responsible for the first line of attack, governor and Liangzhou, commander in chief and Xia.
Jingzhou Legion, responsible for fighting against Shu Han and Wu, guarding the barrier of the Central Plains, defending the security of Xuchang and commanding Coss.
Hebei Liao Army Corps, responsible for the northern border defense, supervising Youzhou and Bingzhou, and commanding Cao Zhang.
Both capital city legion, responsible for protecting Luoyang, commander in chief Cao Xiu.
Yuzhou Legion, Yangzhou Legion's backup, overseers Yanzhou and Yuzhou, is Cao Cao's stronghold, and commander in chief Cao Hong.
Thus, the status of Cao Shi's clansmen in the army is unparalleled.
Therefore, no matter how powerful Guan Yu is, he can't get ahead of these people. But Cao Cao's love and admiration for Guan Yu is true. When Guan Yu took refuge in Cao Cao, Cao Cao not only promised Guan Yu three conditions, but also gave him jewelry and a red rabbit. Even when Guan Yu left, Cao Cao did not embarrass Guan Yu, which shows that Cao Cao was sincere to Guan Yu.
Therefore, in terms of status, Guan Yu should be the first person who can be sent outside the Eight Tiger Riding.
Master Guan's martial arts is not the best in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, but he is respected as a martial artist by later generations. Therefore, on the one hand, Guan Yu still has considerable dominance among the military commanders of the Three Kingdoms. The Shu-Han Camp played by Master Guan was the gathering of the most outstanding generals in the world at that time. Although master Guan is the most famous among them, he is not as good as Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun in terms of hard power. Compared with Mr. Zhang Zhao, Mr. Guan's record seems to be a little watery. For example, Yan Liang and Wen Chou did not show their true strength for various reasons; It is difficult to win dozens of rounds with Ji Ling; Five passes and six generals are all faced with small roles. Compared with Zhang Fei's one-on-one fight with Lu Bu for many times, Lu Bu was frightened, and compared with Zhao Zilong's seven in and seven out, it was a bit gloomy.
However, as mentioned above, the reason why Master Guan is not the most dazzling is largely because his teammates are so excellent. The five tigers will lead the army, and whoever falls into other camps will become the first military commander of that camp. Naturally, if Mr Guan really defected to Cao Cao, the reputation of the first general of Cao Cao would definitely belong to Mr Guan.
According to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, there are many famous soldiers under Cao Cao's account, but their strength is relatively balanced, nothing particularly fierce, but nothing particularly strong. Cao Cao's top eight are Zhang Liao, Huang Xu, Zhang He, Yu Jin and Cao Cao's bodyguards, as well as Cao Cao's two brothers Xia He. But none of these people can beat Master Guan in martial arts.
Of these eight people, Chu Xu is the strongest. When I was in Tongguan, many generals in Cao Ying could do nothing about Ma Chao. Finally, they had to go out with Chu Xu, and the horses were tied. Chu Xu, when Huang Xu was in second place. At the beginning, Huang Xu and Chu Xu fought for fifty rounds, and the outcome was close. It can be seen that martial arts were not much worse than Chu Xu. But these two are really nothing compared with Mr. Guan. When Guan Yu was stationed in Xiapi, Zhang Liao and Guan Er joined hands, but both were killed by Guan Er. You know, Master Guan was at a disadvantage at that time, because Liu Bei's family was still in the city, and Master Guan could not defend the enemy with peace of mind, but he could still repel them. It can be seen that Master Guan's kung fu is higher than these two.
As for Guan Erye, at the end of his life, due to the long-term neglect of war, old age and physical weakness, and the injury to his right arm, he could only exert six or seven points of strength, and it gradually became smooth after eighty rounds of fierce fighting. As you can imagine, Mr. Guan is in a healthy state and there is no problem in defeating him.
So as far as martial arts are concerned, Master Guan is the first of Cao Cao. In terms of fame, don't pass the teacher too much. Warm wine to chop Hua Xiong, chop Yan Liang, punish Wen Chou, this series of achievements is enough to make the world famous, not to mention riding thousands of miles alone. Once upon a time, in America, this excellent quality brought extra points to Master Guan. On the ability to lead troops, in Liu Bei's camp, whenever Liu Bei needs to divide his troops, he always leads the way himself and Guan Yu leads the way, which is enough to show Liu Bei's trust in Guan Yu's ability. Even after Liu Bei entered Sichuan, Guan Yu was the only one guarding Jingzhou. Although Guan Yu finally lost Jingzhou, it also shows that Guan Yu is a talented general who can be independent.
It can be said that if Guan Yu was in Cao Ying, he would be the first famous Cao Ying.
If Guan Yu really voted for Cao Cao, where would he rank in Cao Ying?
This stage depends on Guan Yu's actual life span. Because, if Guan Yu really voted for Cao Cao, there would be no defeat in Maicheng. Although he was shot by an arrow many times, he was narrowly missed. If Guan Yu can live to the age of Cao Pi or even Cao Rui, his position will be higher and his ranking will be higher. For example, in Cao Cao's time, Zhang He, whose position was not very high and his force was not very strong, went to Cao Pi as a general left, and in Cao Rui's time, he rode a general. Of course, if Guan Yu had not lost Jingzhou and gone to Maicheng, his position would have been greatly improved after Liu Bei proclaimed himself emperor. Because Zhang Fei is also a general in the end, Guan Yu may be a general in title of generals in ancient times even if he is not a general. In this case, Ma Chao has to be wronged a little and give up the title of ancient general. The general who got off the bus was Zhang Fei, and he wanted to get off again. Is general Wei similar?
In Cao Wei Group, taking Yu Jin's promotion as an example, in the twenty-first year of Jian 'an (2 16), Cao Cao was promoted to Wang Wei, Yu Jin was appointed as the left general and gave him a false title. At that time, Zhang Liao was an eastern general and was on vacation. Coss at that time was not as good as prohibition. Guan Yu, in the early years of Jian 'an (196- 199), was made a partial general by Emperor Xian of Han Dynasty (about major general and deputy military post), and later joined the Jue Hanshou Pavilion. By the time General Zuo was banned, it had been about twenty years. Not to mention the meritorious military service and others, his qualifications alone have been brilliant and radiant.
However, Yujin was defeated in Xiangfan, which not only made the whole army tired and suffered heavy losses, but also led to its capture. What's more, he bowed and surrendered, in sharp contrast to Pound, who was also captured. Not only let Cao Cao down, but also let the next generation successor Cao Pi look down on him even more. So, to xelloss, the front, back, left and right generals are Zhang Liao, Zhang He, Huang Xu and Zhu Ling. If Guan Yu lived to Xelloss's age, it is estimated that he might be among the generals in all directions.
But it goes without saying that Guan Yu's surname and origin, under the principle of Cao Cao's employment, will inevitably limit and bind Guan Yu's promotion and further progress. Pass, too far away from Xiahou Shi and Cao Shi, has nothing to do with this. Although even Cao Ren was named general of the Southern Expedition in the 24th year of Jian 'an (2 19), there was no false holiday. However, Xia Houdun and Coss have always been Cao Cao's right-hand man. This is not only because Cao Ren and Xia Houdun are predecessors, but more importantly, Cao surname and Xiahou Xing are relatives and friends. It can be seen that although Cao Cao put forward "meritocracy", it does not mean using or distinguishing the distance between relatives and friends. Therefore, if Guan Yu wants to enter the core of Cao Cao, I am afraid it will be difficult to work. Only among the generals with foreign surnames, they stand out and take the lead.
Of course, Guan Yu was in Cao Cao Group, and finally he could develop to that extent, mainly in Guan Yu himself. It includes not only loyalty, ability to deal with major military crises, meritorious service at critical moments, but also hard conditions, such as the closeness between colleagues, subordinates and senior leaders. It is definitely not possible to rely solely on force and rely on old qualifications to make a living. Also, Cao Cao appreciates it, but not necessarily Xelloss likes it. Therefore, after the replacement of Cao Wei Group, how Guan Yu adapts to the adjustment will also test Guan Yu's wisdom, which is obviously not Guan Yu's strength.
To sum up, Guan Yu is in Cao Cao Group, and no matter how hard he works, it is still difficult to surpass Liu Bei Group. If Guan Yu had not lost Jingzhou, Zhang Fei would have been promoted to ride a general. If Guan Yu had not died, at least he would not have been lower than Zhang Fei, or even higher than Ma Chao, who came from behind. It's just that you never know. One careless move will lose the game, and all his hopes and dreams can only be said to be eternal dreams.
"... red-faced Guan Yu beat Changsha, yellow-faced Dian Wei, white-faced Cao Cao, and black-faced Zhang Fei called scum ..." Red face represents loyalty, yellow face represents courage and bravery, black face represents integrity, selflessness and integrity, and white face represents insidious and cunning.
Then, if Master Guan defected to Cao Cao in history, he would be in the top three now.
Guan Yu followed Liu Bei in his early days and was captured alive by Cao Cao. In the battle of Guandu, Guan Yu and Zhang Liao were both pioneers of Cao Jun. They saw Yan Liang's Beggars' Sect from a distance in Bai Mapo, and suddenly wielded a knife to slay Yan Liang among all the troops. Yuan Jun's generals and people can stop him. The siege of the white horse was solved, and Guan Yu sealed the Hanshou Pavilion. The attack on Yan Liang reflected Guan Yu's one-on-one fight and bravery, and Dian Wei and Chu Xu were the brave men in Cao Cao.
If Guan Yu had stayed with Cao Cao at this time, the ranking of Cao Cao's "Five Talents" (Zhang Liao, Yu Jin, Le Jin, Huang Xu and Zhang He) would not be like this. But Guan Yu finally returned to Liu Bei, ranking first among Liu Bei's "Five Tiger Generals".
In 208 AD, Cao Cao marched south and Liu Bei fled south, which led Guan Yu to lead the water army to divide troops into Jiangling. It can be seen that if Liu Bei divides his troops, that is, Guan Yu leads the army, Guan Yu will be appointed as the defeated army. He has the talent of a general and is worthy of the heavy responsibility.
After Battle of Red Cliffs and Liu Bei obtained the four counties in Jingnan, Guan Yu was promoted to the founding father and was named the prefect and general of Xiangyang. At this time, Xiangyang was Cao Cao's territory, where Lejin was stationed and Guan Yu was stationed in Jiangbei.
In 2 14, Liu Bei was frustrated when he entered Sichuan, and Zhang Fei, Zhuge Liang and Zhao Yun were called for support, leaving Guan Yu alone in Jingzhou. After Liu Bei besieged Shu, Guan Yu was in Jiangling, and Du Dong was in Jingzhou, so they could command operations in large groups.
In the autumn and July of 2 19, Guan Yu launched the Xiangfan War. Guan Yu took advantage of the surging Han River to annihilate the Seventh Army in Sanzhoukou and won an unprecedented victory.
What's more, it is worth mentioning that it is better to be captured alive in Yanliang than to be killed. Yujin's position under Cao Cao's account is extraordinary, higher than that of Zhang Liao and Huang Xu. Yu Jin, who has been through many battles and is famous for his fortitude and seriousness, is in awe of all the soldiers of Cao Jun.
Guan Yu had a great influence on China, and Cao Cao once had the idea of moving the capital. He sent Huang Xu, a bandit-born general, into China and defeated Guan Yu. Guan Yu was forced to abandon the siege of Fancheng. Huang Xu was highly praised by Cao Cao, saying that "the general has more work than Sun Wu and Mao".
On the occasion of Guan Yu's northern expedition to Xiang and Fan, Sun Quan attacked the public security from behind, leaving Guan Yu under attack. This fully exposed Guan Yu's shortcomings in commanding large-scale group operations. As far as military affairs are concerned, Guan Yu fought alone and was carried away by the victory of Xiangfan.
At this point, Zhang Liao is higher than Guan Yu. In AD 2 15, Sun Quan led an army to the Northern Expedition, and Zhang Liao commanded the First World War between Hefei and xiaoyaojin. Sun Quan escaped in distress and lost his famous soldier Ling Tong. Since then, Soochow has never crossed Hefei. Zhang Liao, 10 yuan each, is immortal in the battle commanded by big groups.
To be fair, Guan Yu's historical position is roughly equal to that of Zhang Liao and Huang Xu. Zhang He was defeated by Zhang Fei in the battle of Party Canal, and the whole army was wiped out. Only a dozen people fled back through the mountains. Compared with Guan Yu, it is far from enough.
But Guan Yu is a mythical figure, and there is such a couplet that says it well: "Write a spring and autumn period and read a spring and autumn period, and Confucius is a saint."
If Mr. Guan defected to Cao Cao, where would he rank in Cao Cao's camp? There is no need to join this question. Guan Yu had already surrendered to Cao Cao. In "romance", it is basically nonsense to comfort yourself.
But I have to admit that when Cao Cao knew that Guan Yu didn't really want to stay in Cao Ying and sent Zhang Liao to test him, Guan Yu said bluntly that he would work for Cao Cao and that he would go to Liu Bei. Finally, I went to find the old master by "printing gold and riding thousands of miles alone". I have to admire Guan Yu for this. It is precisely because of this that Guan Yu will be regarded as a "loyal man" by future generations. The original text is as follows:
So what? If Guan Yu didn't leave Cao Cao at the beginning, but really worked for Cao Cao, where would he rank? Sure! His position cannot surpass that of Xia, Cao Hong, Coss and others. So it can only be compared with foreign generals.
After Guan Yu voted for Cao Cao, he was worshipped as a partial general with great courtesy. But that's all. It is completely different from the treatment of all generals in Romance. When Guan Yu killed Yan Liang and made great contributions to Cao Cao, he was named Hou Ting of Hanshou, and his rank and position were still partial to general. After that, Guan Yu left Cao Ying.
Let's compare it with other generals, such as Cao Wei's general, a man named "Wuzi Good General".
When Zhang Liao first joined Cao Cao, he was appointed as a corps commander and was awarded the title of Commissioner of Customs.
Zhang Hechu voted for Cao Ying, was named partial general, and was awarded the title of Hou Ting.
When Huang Xu first joined Cao Cao, he kept his original official title, because his capital was appointed by the Emperor of Heaven not long ago.
Pound voted for Cao Ying first, was worshipped as General Yi Li, and closed the door of Hou Ting, where there were 300 families.
He said that when he entered Cao Cao, he was the prefect of Jiangxia and was named the Hou of Shanhaiguan.
These generals were all surrendered to Cao Wei by other vassal forces. Judging from the treatment Cao Cao gave them, almost all of them were knighted. The official position is no less than Guan Yu's partiality. It shows that Cao Cao's attitude towards Guan Yu is the same as that of these valiant soldiers, and there is no special preferential treatment.
Just "kind", because Zhang Liao and Zhang He's famous Cao Cao are both "kind".
So! Guan Yu wants to be promoted all the way and can't enjoy special treatment. He must be supported by his record, and he has as many records as Wu, so that he can have a position equivalent to Wu.
In terms of military ability, Guan Yu and Cao Wei's five sons are not much different, and they are all top stars in the Three Kingdoms period. If he really works for Cao Wei, according to his performance in Shu Han, his achievements should be no less than Wuzi.
So! His position is probably similar to that of a good soldier.