Reflections on the film Life on Earth 1
"Winning with truth" and "Truth is the most powerful" ... Almost overnight, The World on Earth became an instant hit, with Douban score of 9.7 and as many short comments as 1508. The documentary film 10, which shows hospital life, has the most evaluation: truthfulness.
Is Life on Earth true? I really didn't feel it, because there was no scene in which patients waited in line for hours but met an impatient doctor, there was no scene in which doctors suddenly changed their faces when they couldn't afford the money, and there was no scene in which doctors tried their best to persuade patients to use expensive drugs. ...
Documentaries use many images that are common in film and television works, such as flying nurses, fast-moving sickbeds, flying ambulances, flashing warning lights, fast-moving hemostatic forceps and scalpels. However, the common images in life, such as nurses yelling loudly, labyrinthine laboratories, and cleaning in the inpatient department every morning, are still missing.
Front-line doctors are particularly hard, and most medical workers are very responsible and full of mission. There is no doubt about this, but it does not mean that we should ignore many unsatisfactory phenomena in medical services and even have institutional defects.
In contrast, the world presented to the audience by Human Life is too perfect, only seeing the problems of insufficient medical resources, technical bottlenecks and no one, which does not completely match many people's medical experience, and may produce two results: First, patients have high expectations for hospital services, and when they are dissatisfied, they tend to overreact and become "medical troubles"; Secondly, if we only see the need to improve technology and fail to see the need to improve services, the future funds will still be concentrated in the former, but the income of medical staff will never be greatly improved. They are only accessories of technological development. Can such good equipment really give full play to its value?
From the perspective of depicting hospital ecology, life on earth is not completely true, why can it impress so many audiences? Why can you get such a high score from netizens? Because Life on Earth expresses another truth, that is, life is fragile, and each of us will eventually fail.
For life, death is cold and eternal. In the face of death, all values are so fragile. If you only have one life, why should you live seriously? Why insist on it for love and sincerity? If the outcome is the same, is everything we once clung to still valuable? The infatuation, intoxication and enthusiasm we once had.
It is precisely because of the great deconstruction of value by death that all civilizations throughout the ages are trying to cover up death. We believe with a grain of salt that there is another world waiting for us, and death is just a rebirth. However, when reality has exposed lies countless times, modern people have to hide their death-through hospitals, funeral institutions, cemeteries and so on. , to minimize the impact of death. As a result, death has become an "accidental" event and an accident and taboo in daily discourse. Therefore, most modern people can only get the experience of death from the death of their closest relatives.
When death becomes a stranger, the world will be perfect, everything has a reason, and everything can be grasped. We are used to this way of thinking: there is no accident, and someone must be negligent behind the accident, which must be the result of inadequate accountability.
Life on Earth is shocking precisely because it shows death naked to the public. Many people found for the first time that there is no reason for death, and cruelty is the background of life.
Yes, traffic jams will make hard-won donated hearts completely useless; Because of negligence, a strong young man suddenly fell down; In order to become a mother again, the seemingly mature artificial insemination technology has given people so much pain ... "Life is a matter of life" tells us that medicine is not everything. In the face of cold facts, doctors and patients are actually poor people.
Life on earth conveys a universal feeling that we are all human beings and we are all suffering from fate. Please don't indulge in complaining about each other because of ignorance and pride.
Love is not eternal. When you have it, think of the pain when you lose it. Life is not firm, when you are immersed in it, you should think that everything will end; Happiness is unreliable, when you embrace it, think about its hypocrisy; Science is limited, and when you benefit from it, it will also bring you a lot of disappointment.
In a sense, Life on Earth supplements the deficiencies in our education and culture. When the world trend is sliding towards luxury and enjoyment, it tells us the nothingness of this shore in time. Compared with the slow-motion and poetic description of appetite in China on the Tip of the Tongue, Life on Earth is heavy and therefore true.
Through "China on the Tip of the Tongue", people will only regret that there are so many delicious things, but through "Life on Earth", people can lament that everything we once loved is so illusory, thus thinking more deeply: Since life is fragile, how can I spend this life?
Although it didn't reach the truth of criticizing reality, it touched the truth of life philosophy, so The World on Earth is still true and touched hundreds of millions of viewers.
However, the truth of life philosophy is the truth constructed in research, which is far from the vividness and vividness of concrete life. In the absence of philosophy of life education, human life is advanced, which fills some gaps. However, as society crosses this stage, human life will lose its value because of the gap with reality. After all, it is the truth after editing, not the witness of an era.
Once the philosophy of life is pushed to the extreme, it will inevitably slide to rigidity, rigidity and even opposition. For example, in The World on Earth, the deliberate display of the patient's beating heart and the direct presentation of human organs all use sensory stimulation to strengthen the significance of the theme of "fragile life", but is this bloody technique appropriate? In a society that values rights more, is this really appropriate? In order to state the grand theme of reverence for life, we do not hesitate to deprive individuals of their dignity, which shows the gap between the producers of human life and modern civilization, and such a documentary can get so much praise, which shows the gap between our whole environment and modern civilization.
Reflections on the film Life on Earth (Ⅱ)
From afternoon to night, I can't come to my senses after reading it in one breath. The table is littered with tissues, free eyes and echoing pictures.
Song Qing said that Life on Earth is a good documentary. I didn't pay much attention to the hospital. Douban scored 9.8, but I was deeply attracted after paying attention to it. I started writing after reading it that day, but after writing two lines, I couldn't write any more until I saw this sentence:
The documentary "Life on Earth" makes people afraid to watch it for the second time because it hits people's hearts directly. It tells the story of human reason and emotion, human fragility and persistence, human desperate nostalgia and unselfishness beyond human nature in the face of life and death. Recorded the joys and sorrows that were staged in the hospital. In the interweaving of hope and disappointment, all emotions are magnified, joy is beyond words, sadness is unbearable, and anger is unstoppable. However, beyond misunderstanding, conflict and chilling, there is always trust, respect and mutual understanding. It makes people relive a truth between new life and parting: everything will be lost to time, and everyone will come and go naked. It makes people understand that nothing in the world is greater than life and death.
What will you do when life is so simple that there is only one goal-to live?
This person is you lying in a hospital bed, with all kinds of instruments plugged in. What you can see is a white roof, surrounded by the same white. Or someone you love is lying in bed. Can you sign the operation sheet? Can you bear great economic pressure? Can bear the emotions of fear, sadness and anger. When you find that doctors are not omnipotent at all, what should you do if you try your best to save people without knowing the result?
The truth is that you have to put up with it. When life and death are really in front of me, I can't imagine what kind of heart some comfort will be.
Seeing this, I hope you will read it first, and then come back and feel it with me.
We often talk about gratitude. We should thank our parents, teachers, relatives, friends and everyone around us because I love them. Then let your love become stronger! Cherish our time, pay our own efforts, and pay the ability to learn and gain. Let your shoulders bear more.
Now I have decided to take my whole family to the hospital for a physical examination every year, and I can find out in time that I can exercise and strengthen my physique on weekdays. It may take some money and time, but it's all worth it.
The right to life has always been in your hands, but you never realized it.
Therefore, life should not only be strong, but also know how to cherish it. Only those who know how to cherish will always take care of their health. Because health is not only about your wealth, but also about the happiness of the people you love.
Help, understanding, joining the league, farewell, choice, trust, rebirth, persistence, love, life is staged every day, and the next one may be yourself. Are you ready?
Reflections on the film "Life on Earth" 3
It's been three years since this documentary was broadcast, but its influence has not gradually declined because of the passage of time. This documentary directly attacks the contradiction between doctors and patients, shows people real medicine with life stories, and makes people think more when facing diseases, and does not avoid talking about failure, life and death, respecting medicine and life.
Doctors may have become a vulnerable group in the doctor-patient relationship now, which directly leads to the fact that the enrollment of medical universities is not as hot as in previous years, but gradually deserted, and the profession of doctors is becoming a daunting task in China. The reason is that doctors are under too much pressure, not only from practicing medicine to save people, but also from patients' families. This double pressure scared off some people who originally planned to become doctors.
Sometimes it's healing, often it's helping, always comforting. The truth of medicine is that when brilliant doctors can't do anything, many cases of "hurting doctors" are behind because many patients' families can't accept the gap between their desire for life and the existing medical level, which also causes great psychological pressure on doctors.
In the face of diseases, patients' families can give doctors full trust, let doctors really play their duties and do their best to save every patient. Maybe this should be our real pursuit.
Yes, this is a means that many rural women's rights often use to attack society and mislead women from the media.
But this sentence was said by a doctor in the documentary. The reason is that this hospital has accepted many expectant mothers gathered here from all over the country. Their bodies are very unfit to have children, and their lives are in great danger, but doctors can't directly abort these children, because most of these expectant mothers are very eager to have a child, and they have the right to choose to have this child.
What impressed me the most was a expectant mother with a heart problem. If she wants to have a baby, she is at great risk of dying during childbirth.
To the disappointment of some rural women's rights, the whole family, parents-in-law, parents, husbands and sisters all opposed the mother-in-law to have children, but the mother still knew the risks and took risks to have children.
Another expectant mother is a martyr's family member, and the only child is a fire fighter. In a fire fighting mission, she died heroically for the country and the people. Behind the hero is a broken family. In the face of an empty home, the expectant mother hopes to have another child and give this family a sustenance, but this expectant mother is old and it is risky to have a baby.
Unfortunately, expectant mothers with heart problems gave birth smoothly. At the age of 28 weeks, the child was delivered by caesarean section and passed the first stage of the operating table perfectly. However, in the postoperative icu, due to heart problems, she still failed to survive. He left without even seeing the child himself.
The mother of another martyr survived the risk of giving birth at an advanced age.
Reflections on the film "Life on Earth" 4
Many episodes ended in tears, and the doctor-patient relationship is often the headline news now. Doctors in documentaries often say that medicine is not omnipotent, and doctors can save lives within a limited range of abilities, but people are in danger and medicine can do nothing. In the first episode, there is a clip of emergency room rescue, in which doctors do CPR in shifts. The rescue failed, and a doctor took off his mask and left. Perhaps this rescue is an unusual one he has experienced in his career. Maybe this patient is a part of his life and death, but when he took off his mask and bowed his head and walked away, I think he still had sadness in his heart. After all, the patient is only 24 years old.
Organ donation sounds like a very important topic. In China's traditional concept, the idea that the body is influenced by parents, and the soul is reincarnated after death, and cremation needs to be popularized by the state, not to mention how much determination the living need to make and how much grief they have to endure. When Jiao's parents made a decision, they were most impressed by the need for the guardian to give up treatment by hand in the procedure. Handwriting is like giving up my favorite son. At this time, my father hesitated, but my mother was unusually calm. My son's life could not be saved, so he became a part of other excellent people and lived in this world. At the end of this episode, there is an organ donation monument, not only telling the living, but also telling these people that their relatives are thinking about other unrelated people who are sick while suffering from bereavement.
Have you ever thought about the future, how your life will end, hospice care hospital, if one day you have to endure pain and how to die with dignity, it takes courage to choose suicide. Sometimes you haven't got up the courage, but even this choice has been lost, because at that time you have no strength, so death is a relief. To live is to watch the pain of spring, summer, autumn and winter through four windows in a small bed, which is something everyone should think about. When the seriously ill old man left, his wife couldn't help crying in the car when she took a taxi to send her the last journey. In this life, two people hold hands, but one of them left first. The pain is the same regardless of age and health.
26-year-old young mother, this episode is the most touching. The love of the newlyweds, the pregnant mother's persistence to the last moment for her children, and the brave and optimistic face of the disease always comes suddenly. There is no reason why there is no substitute. Living is a luxury. Do you live a full life every day?
Reflections on the film "Life on Earth" 5
This documentary just aired the first episode, and everyone said, "Ruijin Hospital is really courageous!" Many people are saying these days: Ruijin Hospital is very enterprising. Because the medical documentary "Life on Earth" filmed in a number of 3A hospitals in Shanghai was broadcast on June 1 1, the first episode broke the routine and presented several failed cases to the audience-a 24-year-old youth who failed to recover from multiple organ failure due to eating seafood poisoning, a Marfan syndrome patient who failed to survive the next day after surgery ... The hospital filmed in the first episode was Ruijin!
This is the first time that a medical documentary has faced the "imperfection" of medicine in such a large space. "The routine of the general story is that the patient's life is on the line, the operation is thrilling, and finally it is a great success. When the patient leaves the hospital, he will thank the doctor. However, risky operations always fail, and we seem to be used to avoiding failure. " Today, we can finally talk objectively about what real medical care is like.
"Life is very painful. It's good to have you." "At first, I was worried that the failure case would lead to incomprehension." This is the voice that the reporter heard in Ruijin Hospital. After all, not all hospitals have such courage. Fortunately, it was well received. "I have seen too many' perfect' medical propaganda, and this angle is even more touching. Failure is also something that doctors and their families must face, and it is incomplete to talk about medical care without this topic. Life is painful, it's good to have you! " "It is very objective and positive. I think we need such propaganda to restore the true nature of medical care, with efforts and failures. " "We have organized hundreds of rescues. We succeeded and failed. Only by understanding this kind of pain can we resolutely protect the last acre of land in our hearts. Doctors are people, not gods. "
Many medical staff type these words in the circle of friends. Someone commented, "Dare to face the failure of peace talks, which in itself is a kind of progress. Dare to face the truth, itself is a kind of sublimation. Carrying forward the truth and rebuilding honesty is one of the missions of intellectuals in this era. " The vast majority of people said that they understood the doctor's hard work and helplessness after reading it.
Doctors will be annoyed and uncomfortable when they meet hopeless patients. The success on the operating table will make the doctor extremely happy. Rescue is always a race against time, and it is common for doctors to cover the life-saving plasma from the blood bank with their hands.
There will be such a scene, the operation is still going on, but the family members have rushed in and grabbed the doctor's neck ... "I will do my best when I am alive", saying that no doctor has faced failure, which is not objective at first. A professor from a 3A hospital told the reporter the most impressive case, which he called "a robbery".
At that time, he was still a young resident. A patient with severe trauma came in the evening. He is in his twenties. The operation lasted until two or three in the morning. After the operation, he saw the patient. No problem. He went to bed exhausted. The next day, the patient was observed, the skin flap turned white, the blood circulation could not go up, and the patient was in hemorrhagic shock. Many first-aid measures were taken, but none of them were saved.
"The patient died and I lost." The professor talked about his feelings at that time. Maybe the details of the operation were better handled, maybe the patient was observed more carefully after the operation, maybe the patient changed like this ... the young resident collapsed.
Then an old doctor let him out. "The revolution was sacrificed. You can't have major surgery when you are young. When you grow up, the cost is deeper. " After that, no matter how late the operation was finished in the morning, the young doctor stayed with the patient to observe the situation. This is a test of physical strength and willpower, but he just never gives up and does not allow any mistakes in his own links.
There is a particularly good sentence in "Life of Man": "The hardest thing for a doctor is not to face failure. The hardest thing is to face all kinds of setbacks caused by these failures without losing the initial enthusiasm. "
Zhao Qiang, director of cardiac surgery at Ruijin Hospital, is an example of this sentence. In the first episode, he first treated Wang Bin, a 27-year-old patient with Marfan syndrome, a congenital disease called "death pronoun". The patient's aorta will tear at any moment, and he died of massive bleeding. Most patients don't live past 30.
In order to save him, we have to replace the aorta of the whole body with an artificial blood vessel, which is equivalent to "half a person has to cut it", which is a major operation. Zhao Qiang had an operation. Zhao Qiang is going to operate on Marfan syndrome, which is a major operation in cardiac surgery. All the aorta in the patient's body should be replaced with artificial blood vessels. Unfortunately, the day after the operation, Wang Bin suffered from acute renal failure and did not survive.
Soon, another Marfan syndrome patient, Jing Liu, came to Ruijin Hospital. Zhao Qiang, who just experienced a failure, didn't reject the family. He didn't care too much about the blow of the second failure and the impact on his reputation. "The girl's father and brother died suddenly because of Marfan's syndrome. If I don't operate on him, her life may be suspended at any time. " The day after the broadcast of Life on Earth, the reporter met Zhao Qiang. Recalling this case, he said two words: "If you don't succeed, you will die, and you will not consider fame and fortune. The patient comes first." Every case is different, and there are no identical cases. After 32 hours of surgery and the cooperation of 9 doctors, Jing Liu was discharged alive this time.
Zhao Qiang said, I hope that through this documentary, everyone will know that every patient and every doctor will try their best to treat him, but we must also understand that there are always some places that cannot be achieved by medicine.
Although there were failures, more people survived. People familiar with Zhao Qiang will find that this kind of doctors have one characteristic: simple personality. In the final analysis, the top priority in their minds is those two words: help.
"I will do my best in my lifetime." We should have such trust and belief in doctors.
A respected old academician in the medical field once said that if all diseases can be saved, that person will not die, but won't he die? Therefore, life is unbearable pain, whether you admit it or not.
Duan Tao, dean of Shanghai First Maternal and Infant Health Hospital, who successfully rescued women with amniotic fluid embolism, once said, "The amniotic fluid embolism that can be rescued is probably not amniotic fluid embolism." . These words, on the one hand, talk about the harm of amniotic fluid embolism, on the other hand, there are too many insurmountable peaks, too many changes and unknowns in medicine.
Then why are we talking about failure? Is it just to be convinced by failure and defeated? No. When we talk about cases of failure, we are actually talking about experiencing grief and regaining hope.
Review related articles of the 2022 film "Life on Earth";
★ In 2022, there were 6 articles about the world.
★ Five 800-word compositions about the world.
★ 6 essays on human feelings.
★ Model essay on human documentary review
★ 10 2022 first prize composition "learning from a powerful country" and my family's "the story of the world"
★10 Excellent composition of My Family's Story on Earth in 2022.
★ Learn the theme composition of my motherland's human story 10 2022
★ 2022 My Family's Theme Composition on "World"
★ Learn ten essays on human stories in China in 2022.
★10 essays on human stories in China in 2022.