Interviewed civil servants and judges told reporters that this leap-forward promotion, whether combined with their own experience or in accordance with the relevant provisions on the promotion and appointment of civil servants, is incredible. Among the young cadres promoted by xintai city, 23-year-old Wang Ran and 25-year-old Liu Tingting received the most questions. According to the publicity materials on the website of xintai city Municipal Government, Wang Ran, female, from Xintai, Shandong Province, was born in July 1986, with a bachelor's degree in management and a bachelor's degree in economics. He is currently a member of the case trial room of xintai city Commission for Discipline Inspection, and is proposed to be the deputy director of xintai city State-owned Assets Administration Bureau. Liu Tingting, female, from Xintai, Shandong Province, 1984 12, with a university degree, is currently an assistant judge of the filing court of Daiyue District People's Court, and is proposed to be the vice president of xintai city People's Court. Although the two have publicly responded to some sensitive topics before, there are still some problems that confuse the public. Fang Ming said that according to Article 19 of the Regulations on the Appointment, Removal and Promotion of Civil Servants (Trial), "those who are promoted to deputy leadership positions at the township level should hold department-level positions for more than three years". In addition, Article 32 of the Civil Service Law stipulates that "the probation period for newly hired civil servants is one year", while Article 4 of the Regulations on the Classification of Newly Employed Civil Servants stipulates that "the term of office of newly hired civil servants shall be counted from the date of expiration of the probation period". "That is to say, Wang Ran should have at least four years of work experience when taking the exam, and she should start working at least in July 2005." Fang Ming said. According to Wang Ran's public response, she was admitted to the university in 2003 and graduated from the university in 2007 and admitted to the civil service. As for Liu Tingting, a judge of the Beijing Basic Court who asked not to be named also expressed his doubts to reporters. He said that according to Article 11 of the Judges Law, the presidents of local people's courts at various levels are elected and removed by local people's congresses at various levels, and vice presidents, members of judicial committees, presidents, vice presidents and judges are submitted by the presidents of the courts to the standing committees of the people's congresses at the corresponding levels for appointment and removal. "Generally speaking, the vice president is an appointment system, and the organization department has recommended qualifications, but now it is puzzling to appoint directly. From the assistant judge to the vice president, it is hard to imagine what such a young man can do. "Some government department staff interviewed by the reporter also questioned the group of' post-80 s' deputy directors of Xintai based on their own experiences." I am also a farmer, but it is rare for a 29-year-old undergraduate to take a minor. "A civil servant told reporters. The staff of another government department said that he graduated from a key university and was rated as excellent every year. However, it is unbelievable that Wang Ran sat in that position in such a short time. However, many people understand Xintai's promotion of post-80s officials. "Now, the post-80s generation has been able to play a leading role in grass-roots organs all over the country, and many outstanding people are engaged in important work. We can't be biased against the newly promoted post-80s generation. As far as Xintai is concerned, after all, it is open selection and open competition. As long as the procedures are strictly standardized, the ability of the selected candidates should still be affirmed. "