In the eighth chapter of the novel, there is the following description: I saw a woman rowing at the stern, with long hair shawl, white fluttering, a gold belt tied to her hair, and white snow shining. Guo Jing froze and looked at the girl dressed like a fairy. As the boat slowly approached, I saw that the woman was young, but she was fifteen or sixteen years old. Her skin was more beautiful than snow and her face was absolutely beautiful. I didn't dare to stare at her.
This is a direct description of Huang Rong's appearance and clothing, and this article takes it as a contrast.
Huang Rong of Barbara Yung is dressed in blue and doesn't look like he is fifteen or sixteen. In later episodes, Weng Huang Rong also said a lot of rude words. If compared with the original, she has flaws, but this does not prevent her from being the most classic in many people's minds. Sculpture carries too much emotion. Barbara Yung may not be the closest Huang Rong to the original, but it may be the best TV series in Huang Rong.
Athena Chu
The 94 version of Athena Chu is dressed in green and white, and Athena Chu plays a cute and clever role, but the skin color is slightly different from the original "Laugh with Skin and Don't Laugh with Meat". Generally speaking, Rong Er of Xia Zixianzi is also very good, and both she and Weng Ban have a very large fan base.
Zhou Xun
In order to increase the artistic conception, the director of Zhou Xun Edition asked Huang Rong to play the piano. This adaptation is also possible. Zhou Xun acted very well on TV, but he was cheated by two things. One is the plait made by the stylist, and the other is the late dubbing, which is too loud for many viewers in Huang Rong. By the way, another highlight of this edition is the theme song "Heaven and Earth in My Heart", which is magnificent and heroic, perhaps second only to the existence of "Iron Heart".
Ariel Lin
For the 08 edition, many people are against it, not because of Hugh, but because of the chubby Huang Rong, which makes everyone fondle admiringly. Although there are boats in this version, the clothing is mainly white, supplemented by orange, but Ariel Lin suddenly appears in the grass, and the 08 version as a whole is not as good as the previous ones.
whitehairpin
The latest 17 version of whitehairpin's evaluation is very good, in line with the appearance of the novel. He is dressed in white, singing and wearing a gold belt, but he lacks the description of rowing, which is almost close to restoring the novel. In the following plot, apart from a large number of adaptations of the emotional lines of Yang Kang and Mu Nianci, the lines of Guo Jing and Huang Rong are still quite loyal to the original works, so many people think that whitehairpin is the Huang Rong closest to Jin Yong's original intention.
Everyone likes each version, but it is not contradictory, because people of different ages live in different times.