The first TV series of A Dream of Red Mansions is version 1987, which is also a classic version that everyone has seen. But 20 10 remake a version, and even invited Yang Yang to play Jia Baoyu, but the final effect was not ideal. There are three main reasons why 10 version is not as good as 87 version. First, the cast and shooting attitude are obviously insufficient; Second, the 10 version focuses on love and cannot show the heavy sense of history; Third, costume props and roles are too delicate and full of modern manufacturing sense.

The cast and shooting attitude of A Dream of Red Mansions are obviously not as good as the 87 version. It was born in the most active and colliding times. At that time, in order to make this TV series well, even the crew invited Shen Congwen, wu shichang, Zhou and other great writers.

At that time, the crew set up a Dream of Red Mansions actor class in Yuanmingyuan, Beijing, in order to let the actors get into the play better. The shooting goal of the crew was only 1, that is, to shoot a Dream of Red Mansions as a work of art.

However, in contrast, the 10 version of A Dream of Red Mansions is obviously not as powerful as the 87 version. Moreover, it should be noted that in order to restore the scene, version 87 is really a national scene. The 10 version is more shot in studios and artificial attractions, lacking realism. In fact, the emotional lines of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu and Xue Baoyu in the 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions are not unique, but reflect social phenomena through their emotional lines. However, the 10 version takes the emotional line as the main theme, and the obvious height is very different.

10 version is also an era of consumption and entertainment, so the crew is more willing to adapt to the characteristics of this era and shoot emotional dramas for young people, but they also lose the essence of their works!

Costume props, roles are too delicate, full of modern manufacturing sense. People who have seen the 87th edition of A Dream of Red Mansions should have a sense of the ancient costume path inside, which is very historical. This effect is inseparable from the person in charge of costume props at that time. The costume props of version 87 were in the charge of Shen Congwen, who was also a literary giant. The degree of concern can be imagined.

10 version of the costume props are exquisite, but there is always a sense of modern imitation.

In addition to costume props, there are people. 10 version of the characters are too delicate, all white and beautiful, and simply do not reflect the characteristics of the characters. For example, the essence of Lin Daiyu is decline, but this feeling is completely invisible in the 10 version!

abstract

Although the times are developing, the pursuit of art is declining. In order to enter the market quickly and make profits, it is difficult for the current TV drama market to surpass the previous era.